
ALT Summary card. Year one is the tell: every FBS head-coaching hire, 1971–2021 (984). Share whose program was better in years 3–4 than the season before the coach arrived, by SRS: year one fell 10+ percentile points, 25% (329 hires); flat, 66% (380); rose 10+, 84% (275). 12% of bad year ones turned into a clearly better program. Hot names 59% vs. 64% for other sitting head coaches. Four of five measures agree strongly. Year-one swings are 17% bigger since 2021. When year one goes backward, it usually stays backward.

ALT Chart of playoff teams by losses at selection. 4-team era (2014-23, 40 teams): 16 with 0 losses, 24 with 1. 12-team actual (2024-25, 24 teams): 2 with 0, 10 with 1, 10 with 2, 2 with 3. 24-team field using each year's final CFP top 24 (48 teams): 2 with 0, 11 with 1, 16 with 2, 18 with 3, 1 with 4 (Iowa 8-4). In the field with 3+ losses, 2024: Alabama 9-3, Ole Miss 9-3, South Carolina 9-3, Clemson 10-3, Iowa State 10-3, Missouri 9-3, Illinois 9-3, Syracuse 9-3, Colorado 9-3, UNLV 10-3. 2025: Alabama 10-3, Texas 9-3, USC 9-3, Arizona 9-3, Michigan 9-3, Virginia 10-3, Houston 9-3, Georgia Tech 9-3, Iowa 8-4. First team out: 10-2 Memphis (2024), 11-2 North Texas (2025). Source: CFP selection committee final rankings.




















